InsWeb Insurance Blog

Are Democrats Less Patriotic Than Republicans?

September 9, 2008 | By: Guest Writer | Comments ( 0 ) | Posted in: Offbeat

What if our patriotism was measured by the type of car we drove? Would we be more patriotic if we drove American cars? What would that say about our political party affiliation? According to data from InsWeb.com's customers, it looks like people living in Republican "Red" states could be considered slightly more patriotic than those who live in Democratic "Blue" states, since American cars are more common ( 66% market share) in Red states vs. Blue states (56% market share).

 

(Toss-Up states are close to the national averages of 60% American cars vs. 40% foreign cars.) (See Vehicle Origin Chart)

vehicle_origin_graph.jpg

 

Of all American cars in the database, 42% are in Democratic states, 38% in Republican states, and 20% in Toss-Up states (see Party composition graph). Of the foreign cars, 50% are in Democratic states, 30% in Republican states, and 20% in Toss-Up states.

 

party_composition_graph.jpg

 

If we look at individual states by ranking the percentage of American car market share, the states with the least amount of American cars (See Table 1) are mostly Democratic. The states with the least amount of foreign cars are mostly Republican.

 

Table 1

State

American

Foreign

Party

Hawaii

39%

61%

Democratic

California

43%

57%

Democratic

Washington, DC

47%

53%

Democratic

Massachusetts

48%

52%

Democratic

New Jersey

49%

51%

Democratic

Connecticut

49%

51%

Democratic

Maryland

52%

48%

Democratic

Rhode Island

52%

48%

Democratic

New York

53%

47%

Democratic

Virginia

55%

45%

Toss-Up

 

However, if you rank by domestic auto dominance 1st (see Table 2), you will notice that only two out of the top 10 states are Democratic states (one of which is Michigan - a state that you would expect to be dominated by American cars because of the abundance of auto plants that exist there), while six are Republican states.

 

Table 2

State

American

Foreign

Party

Michigan

84%

16%

Democratic

North Dakota

81%

19%

Toss-Up

South Dakota

81%

19%

Republican

Iowa

79%

21%

Democratic

Indiana

79%

21%

Republican

Wyoming

78%

22%

Republican

Missouri

76%

24%

Republican

West Virginia

75%

25%

Republican

Nebraska

75%

25%

Republican

Montana

74%

26%

Toss-Up

 

Does this mean that Democrats love our country any less than Republicans? Is it reasonable to conclude that somebody driving a Ford is more patriotic than somebody driving a Toyota?

 

All car and driver data for this article was taken from InsWeb's database of consumers who shopped for Insurance and submitted a lead between January 1st, 2008, and August 25th, 2008. All political data was taken from Pollster.com's main page on August 29th, 2008 (http://www.pollster.com/).

Share this Article:

 

« Storm Season: Hannah, Ike and Josephine Threaten the U.S. | Main | Not-So-Typical Great Movie Car Chases »

Post a comment

(To avoid potential abuse of the commenting system, all comments are subject to approval before posting.)

Home | Archives | About | InsWeb | Contact Us | Free Quotes

InsWeb Powered